feature article
Subscribe Now

Photonics: Where Heat is a Good Thing

Mentor Announces LightSuite for Electro-Optical Design

We all know that person. Everyone in the office is wondering why the heat is turned up. They’re not sweating outright, but they have that just-a-tad-too-warm glow going. And then there’s that one person wearing the jacket. The one that can never seem to get warm enough. Everyone else is trying to shed heat; this person needs more. If only there were a way to get heat from the too-hot people to the too-cold person. Alas…

Low power. Cooler dice. They’re pretty much a thing these days. We spend countless hours designing low-power circuits, better packages, more inventive heat-extraction technologies, all for the purposes of keeping our chips from going nuclear.

Well, it turns out, there’s an exception. There’s that one chip that simply can’t manage to stay warm enough – so much so that it needs a heater.

OK, so, fessing up, it’s not a digital logic die. In fact, its principle function isn’t even analog. No, we’re not talking about MEMSIC’s heated-air accelerometer either. It’s a photonics die.

Which brings us back to a topic we’ve touched a few times before, from a basic primer to a discussion of photonics EDA. But that EDA discussion was about pure photonics. There’s been precious little integration of photonics design with circuit design (other than the merging of DRC into the photonics flow).

Here’s the deal: a large-scale photonics system is… well, still off in the future. But the practical fact of that design is that it will likely involve four difference pieces of silic… – er – semiconductor.

  • Digital logic, on a reasonably modern process node, with features measured in nanometers
  • Analog circuitry, probably on a different die a couple of nodes older than that used for digital logic, with features still measured in nanometers, but probably more of them
  • Photonics, on a 130-nm (or maybe a 65-nm) node, with features measured in microns
  • The laser, which typically uses materials other than silicon.

Each of those dice has tools to make them work, so, if you can manage the interface between the dice, then you can do each design more or less separately – the tools are there for that.

It’s Gettin’ Hot in Here

But it turns out that there’s not quite such a clean break between dice. Yeah, we know we can mix digital and analog if we want to – tools are in place for that. But what about mixing circuits with photonics?

Well, it turns out that mixing just any circuits with photonics is still a ways away. But one pesky aspect of a photonics chip is that the waveguides and such like to stay at a constant temperature. So, while everyone else works on getting heat out of their systems, photonics guys are literally adding heaters to their chips.

And there have been no tools for doing this.

They call it electro-optical design. Yeah, when I heard that phrase, I assumed that this referred to any integration of the electrical with the photonic. After all, it certainly seems plausible that converting from electrical to photonic on a single chip before sending the photons across the network might be faster than transitioning from one die to another first. I’m honestly not sure how those numbers pencil out, but it’s simply not what’s being attempted now. Right now, electro-optical mostly refers to the electric bits that feed the heater.

Electro, Meet Optical

Honestly, at this point, we’re talking low-level design. Much of this still involves manual layout, but managing a layout that combines photonics circuits (OK, they’re not circuits in the strict sense, but… work with me here…) with electrical circuits has been difficult.

So Mentor has announced their LightSute tools to help with this. It’s a script-based approach that works with a photonic compiler to help automate placement and routing. It hooks into Mentor’s Calibre DRC tool, meaning that resulting layouts will be DRC-clean by design. The design acceleration that this provides would appear to be non-trivial: one of their early customers on this, HP, says that a particular 400-element design that would have taken around two weeks to lay out manually was done in 9 minutes, DRC clean.

That whole DRC thing isn’t necessarily obvious, as we’ve seen before. Most DRC is set up to work with straight lines and well-defined corners. (Or, at least, lots of people are working super hard to keep those corners sharp in leading-edge nodes.) But photonics involves curves, which can stay curves with direct-write technologies (great for research). When you go to a normal high-volume mask system, well, GDS2 doesn’t really understand curves well. You need to supply it with a linear approximation, hopefully using lines and corners so short that they can’t resolve, and sort of fuzz into a curve.

But this affects DRC, since, when you’re running DRC, you haven’t fractured the curves yet. And normal DRC rules don’t understand curves. Which is why they use equation-based DRC. Rather than “simply” articulating spacings between features that are assumed to be lines and mostly right angles, features are described and verified mathematically using equations. And equations can describe curves.

Maybe Getting Closer to Analog?

So where’s this all going longer-term? At least as Mentor tells it, it’s pretty unlikely that photonics and digital will cohabitate. The real estate on which the digital logic resides is expensive, and photonics circuits use lots of real estate. It’s like trying to plant a field of hay in the middle of San Francisco; that hay is going to be wayyyy too expensive.

Photonics and the laser? Well, as long as “photonics” means “silicon photonics,” that’s not likely. Silicon is an indirect-bandgap semiconductor, which means that it tends to put out phonons rather than photons. Direct-bandgap semiconductors – which tend to be compound semiconductors like GaAs and InP – can generate and stimulate the photons necessary for lasing. But, because it’s a different material, it gets its own die. That’s not likely to change either.

That leaves analog and photonics. And there is some work ongoing to help merge these design flows. In its early stages, it’s likely to fall short of a fully integrated flow, remaining two flows that exchange files back and forth to get the job done. But… well, you know, baby steps, right? Put some work into automation, and, if demand materializes, put in more work to automate further.

2 thoughts on “Photonics: Where Heat is a Good Thing”

Leave a Reply

featured blogs
May 8, 2024
Learn how artificial intelligence of things (AIoT) applications at the edge rely on TSMC's N12e manufacturing processes and specialized semiconductor IP.The post How Synopsys IP and TSMC’s N12e Process are Driving AIoT appeared first on Chip Design....
May 2, 2024
I'm envisioning what one of these pieces would look like on the wall of my office. It would look awesome!...

featured video

Introducing Altera® Agilex 5 FPGAs and SoCs

Sponsored by Intel

Learn about the Altera Agilex 5 FPGA Family for tomorrow’s edge intelligent applications.

To learn more about Agilex 5 visit: Agilex™ 5 FPGA and SoC FPGA Product Overview

featured paper

Altera® FPGAs and SoCs with FPGA AI Suite and OpenVINO™ Toolkit Drive Embedded/Edge AI/Machine Learning Applications

Sponsored by Intel

Describes the emerging use cases of FPGA-based AI inference in edge and custom AI applications, and software and hardware solutions for edge FPGA AI.

Click here to read more

featured chalk talk

ROHM Automotive Intelligent Power Device (IPD)
Modern automotive applications require a variety of circuit protections and functions to safeguard against short circuit conditions. In this episode of Chalk Talk, Amelia Dalton and Nick Ikuta from ROHM Semiconductor investigate the details of ROHM’s Automotive Intelligent Power Device, the role that ??adjustable OCP circuit and adjustable OCP mask time plays in this solution, and the benefits that ROHM’s Automotive Intelligent Power Device can bring to your next design.
Feb 1, 2024
14,430 views