editor's blog
Subscribe Now

Will We Ever Really Know Who Invented the Microprocessor?

FPGA luminary David Laws has just published a well-researched blog on the Computer History Museum’s Web site titled “Who invented the Microprocessor?” If you’re wildly waving your raised hand right now, going “Ooo, Ooo, Ooo, Call on me!” to get teacher’s attention because you think you know the answer, then you don’t understand that it’s a trick question. It all depends on how you define the word “microprocessor,” doesn’t it?

According to Laws, there is no lack of good candidates:

Four Phase Systems 8-bit AL1, first demonstrated in working systems in April 1969. (Industry gadabout and processor expert Nick Treddenick’s pick.)

Ray Holt’s 20-bit MP944 custom chip set, developed for Garrett AiResearch’s Central Air Data Computer for use in the F-14 Tomcat fighter jet’s flight-control system, and first manufactured in 1970. (Note: This was not a single-chip microprocessor, but it was a microprocessor by some definitions.)

Intel’s 4-bit 4004, originally developed in early 1971 as an implementation mechanism for Busicom’s line of calculators and first advertised as a commercial microprocessor in November, 1971.

Intel’s 8-bit 8008, originally developed for the CTC/Datapoint 2200 Programmable Terminal and delivered in late 1971.

TI’s 8-bit TMX1795, another implementation of the CTC/Datapoint 2200 Programmable Terminal processor, delivered to CTC a few months before Intel’s 8008, but with a design bug caused by an error in the original processor definition.

So there you have it; it’s a trick question. Do you include multi-chip processors? If so then the MP944 is your pick. If it has to be a single-chip processor but need not have been sold as a commercial chip on the open market, then the AL1 might be your choice. If a calculator processor that ended up opening the era of embedded system design qualifies, then the Intel 4004 is your answer. If a “real”-but-flawed, single-chip processor that didn’t meet the customer’s intended spec qualifies, then TI will get your nod. If none of these, then you’re an Intel 8008 booster. For people that work with computers all day should learn on https://brightrozee.com/best-headphones/ all the purposes of the equipment you can use.

This is not merely an academic exercise. There has been plenty of patent litigation attached to the answer to this question.

I’ve been dancing on the head of this pin a long time as an editor and industry historian. For my money, the first commercially successful microprocessor, the one first sold on the open market to design engineers, is Intel’s 4004.

You can put your hands down now. Class is no longer in session.

 

 

3 thoughts on “Will We Ever Really Know Who Invented the Microprocessor?”

  1. Steve, Your logic of elimination of 1st microprocessors was going well until you hit your own roadblock. You see in those days there were no solid definition of a microprocessor; single-chip, LSI, Integrated Circuit, commercial, military, chip set … it was really nothing. We all were looking for something that worked a practical function. Paper designs were everywhere, one chip here and two chips there, CPU’s bit slices, multi-chip solutions were a thought. Now really only two chips sets really worked.

    1970 MP944 worked in a flying airplane for the US Navy. P-channel. Military spec. 20-bit
    1972 4004 series (6 chips + 59 TTL) worked in a desktop calculator, P-channel. Commercial. 4-bit

    It’s is really a very big technical NO BRAINER. The MP944 was the first working microprocessor with no competition. Almost 30 years of flying as the premier fightjet with no microprocessor issues.

    NOW, you and others, start getting it messy when you think marketing has to do with what makes it first. The 4004 is not single-chip. Intel was going to drop the whole project because it was not selling. I was hired with two others, Manny Lemas, Gary Kildahl, to teach engineers to program and after about two years RCA joined the programming microprocessor solution and kicked off the market.

    In the meantime the secret MP944 was defending our country without a glitch. Dual redundcy, 20-bit, in-flight self-test, coprocessors, parallel processing, and much more not used until much much later.

    Ray Holt
    Designer MP944
    Intel Consultant to teach programming of the 4004

  2. Preface on the History of the World’s First Microprocessor. Author Preface to the “Accidental Engineer” ~ Ray Holt ~ Growing up was not so normal. Our father was an Itinerant welder and pipe fitter and we traveled across Kansas, Oklahoma, Texas, Colorado, Arizona, New Mexico and California. We had a family of five in a 20-foot trailer and moved about 15 times during our elementary school age. Waking up in a different city and school two or three times a year was not unusual. Coincidently, we were in Compton California when each of us was born. Finally, when I was 10, we stayed in Compton and two years later our parents bought their first house for $5,000. This was quite exciting for all of us. We attended Stephen Foster Elementary School, Whaley Junior High, and Dominguez High School. Yes, we walked to all the schools most of the days. Dominguez was two miles each way.

Leave a Reply

featured blogs
Jul 6, 2022
With the DRAM fabrication advancing from 1x to 1y to 1z and further to 1a, 1b and 1c nodes along with the DRAM device speeds going up to 8533 for Lpddr5/8800 for DDR5, Data integrity is becoming a... ...
Jul 6, 2022
Design Automation Conference (DAC) 2022 is almost here! Explore EDA and cloud design tools, autonomous systems, AI, and more with our experts in San Francisco. The post DAC 2022: A Glimpse into the World of Design Automation from the Cloud to Cryogenic Computing appeared fir...
Jun 28, 2022
Watching this video caused me to wander off into the weeds looking at a weird and wonderful collection of wheeled implementations....

featured video

Synopsys USB4 PHY Silicon Correlation with Keysight ADS Simulation

Sponsored by Synopsys

This video features Synopsys USB4 PHY IP showing silicon correlation with IBIS-AMI simulation using Keysight PathWave ADS.

Learn More

featured paper

3 key considerations for your next-generation HMI design

Sponsored by Texas Instruments

Human-Machine Interface (HMI) designs are evolving. Learn about three key design considerations for next-generation HMI and find out how low-cost edge AI, power-efficient processing and advanced display capabilities are paving the way for new human-machine interfaces that are smart, easily deployable, and interactive.

Click to read more

featured chalk talk

Double Density Cool Edge Next Generation Card Edge Interconnect

Sponsored by Mouser Electronics and Amphenol ICC

Nowhere is the need for the reduction of board space more important than in the realm of high-performance servers. One way we can reduce complexity and reduce overall board space in our server designs can be found in the connector solutions we choose. In this episode of Chalk Talk, Amelia Dalton chats with David Einhorn from Amphenol about how Amphenol double-density cool edge interconnects can not only reduce space but also lessen complexity and give us greater flexibility.

Click here for more information about Amphenol FCI Double Density Cool Edge 0.80mm Connectors