feature article
Subscribe Now

Qorvo and the Rare Air of RF

Can Specialization Survive in Semiconductors?

One clear effect of the IoT revolution has been the integration of technology ecosystems that had been independent for decades. Because the IoT is an enormous super-system that takes data from edge nodes through a vast network to the cloud/data center and back again, just about any system we design today ends up connected to every other system being designed. The scope of the communication required is almost incomprehensible, and a large portion of that communication – particularly as we approach the edge – is wireless.

With literally billions of devices transmitting and receiving, the only thing more crowded and more competitive than the RF spectrum is perhaps the set of companies racing to cash in on it. The technical challenges of modern RF are substantial, and the engineering skills and expertise required don’t normally overlap with those we typically find on the digital side of the RF/digital divide. That means a lot of system designers are shopping for their RF technology on the open market.

If you’ve been busy with a project for the past three years or so, you may be prarie-dogging your head up to look around the landscape and wondering “who the heck is Qorvo?” After all, $12 Billion Fortune 500 semiconductor companies with thousands of employees and expansive chip portfolios don’t usually just materialize overnight. But, this one kinda did. Qorvo (What happened to that “u” anyway?) was formed in 2015 by the merger of TriQuint semiconductor and RF Micro Devices. TriQuint (originally a spinoff of Tektronix) had a long history in gallium arsenide (GaAs) semiconductor technology dating back to the mid-1980s. RF Micro Devices (RFMD) was founded in the early 1990s by former Analog Devices employees and, while also a pioneer in GaAs and Gallium Nitride (GaN) technology, had focused on RF design from the get-go, whereas TriQuint spent a sizeable chunk of their early days developing digital GaAs technology.

Because of the insane frequencies that today’s kids expect from their RF toys, GaAs and GaN have been historically much more appropriate than boring old silicon for fabricating the radio-frequency components from antennas through analog-to-digital (ADC) stages. In recent years, more progress has been made on CMOS silicon-based RFICs, as well as silicon-on-insulator (SoI) technology, but those solutions tend to favor integration over performance, and the performance demands on RF components continue to increase.

That means that many applications won’t choose to (or even be able to ) bring the RF part into a monolithic SoC along with all the digital, and that gives us a pretty clean break where competitive lines can currently be drawn and third parties can be invited to even the most heavily vertically integrated system houses. This gives Qorvo – with several decades of GaAs and GaN expertise inherited on both sides of their corporate DNA – a nice sandbox to play in. And, if and when CMOS does continue to make RF inroads, Qorvo’s acquisition of GreenPeak Technologies brings RF Silicon CMOS to the party as well, future-proofing Qorvo’s robust radio-frequency offering.

With channels in the gigahertz ranges stacking up like cordwood, performance of any RF system depends heavily on filtering. For frequencies below 1.5 GHz, surface acoustic wave (SAW) filters were the go-to technology, but as 3G, 4G, and soon 5G demands pile up, as well as proliferation of WiFi devices, bulk acoustic wave (BAW) has become the discerner of choice. Qorvo is banking on their legacy advantages in materials such as GaN, a rich portfolio of SAW and BAW filter technology, and some creative packaging solutions to keep them in the hunt against competitors such as Skyworks in the explosive 5G and IoT RF game.

While each of the RF domains brings its own challenges, there are themes that run throughout the spectrum that will be critical in system design across the board. Filtering, of course, lets us be selective with massive numbers of channels fighting to interfere with our ability to pull signal out of the chaos. In space-constrained and channel-crammed devices such as smartphones, for example, we currently have WiFi, LTE, Bluetooth, 4G/3G all competing, and with 5G the problem gets exponentially worse. Now, watch your customer rest their new smartphone on top of their dual-band 2.4 and 5GHz multi-channel mesh WiFi node, fire up the microwave sitting next to them, wait for that important call to come in – and you get a whole new perspective on the importance of “co-existence filtering.” Perhaps the market could use a little co-existence filtering of its own.

For many system designers, it would be nice to just drop the whole RF part in as a black box and have it work by magic. That’s pretty much where RF is headed. Front-end modules (FEMs) tie the whole thing up with a bow. Typically, a FEM includes power amplifiers, low-noise amplifiers, switches, mixers, and filters. For example, if you are doing a mobile device and really want the “Swiss Army Knife” integration approach, there are modules available that pack 2.4 and 5 GHz 802.11a/b/g/n/ac WiFi Switches with low-noise amplifiers all into a single FEM. Similar levels of integration are available across application domains, from mobile devices to 5G infrastructure, home and commercial WiFi, and IoT edge.

It will be interesting to watch the battle between integration across digital and RF domains on the one hand, and increasing specialization in RF-specific technologies on the other. Companies like Qorvo are banking on the theory that RF performance will be so important that the incessant tug of integration won’t favor an all-silicon-CMOS monolithic do-everything device that brings all the RF onto a giant all-doing SoC. Pulling on the other end of that rope, companies like Qualcomm continue to drive integration of more and more wireless capability – both digital and RF – into their solutions.

Perhaps the growing ecosystem for system-in-package integration will defuse this tension, allowing cost-effective SiPs to be designed that easily intermix and interconnect digital CMOS chiplets with GaN or other RF-friendly process devices, giving the systems engineer the best of all worlds as far as a semiconductor process for each part of the system, while still preserving the benefits of integration via SiP. While we have not yet reached a critical knee in system cost for many applications to go SiP versus monolithic silicon, the day may soon arrive that SiP will be commoditized and supported by a robust design flow.

We hope that happens before the voracious CMOS beast consumes yet another promising and valuable set of interesting technologies. With the inevitable continued rise of the importance of RF in our smart world, that would be a sad step backward.

Leave a Reply

featured blogs
Jul 29, 2021
Circuit checks enable you to analyze typical design problems, such as high impedance nodes, leakage paths between power supplies, timing errors, power issues, connectivity problems, or extreme rise... [[ Click on the title to access the full blog on the Cadence Community sit...
Jul 28, 2021
Here's a sticky problem. What if the entire Earth was instantaneously replaced with an equal volume of closely packed, but uncompressed blueberries?...
Jul 28, 2021
Hyperscale data centers are driving demand for high-bandwidth Ethernet protocols at speeds up to 800G to support HPC, AI, video streaming, and cloud computing. The post What's Driving the Demand for 200G, 400G, and 800G Ethernet? appeared first on From Silicon To Software....
Jul 9, 2021
Do you have questions about using the Linux OS with FPGAs? Intel is holding another 'Ask an Expert' session and the topic is 'Using Linux with Intel® SoC FPGAs.' Come and ask our experts about the various Linux OS options available to use with the integrated Arm Cortex proc...

featured video

Breakthrough FPGA news from Intel

Sponsored by Intel

As part of the numerous portfolio announcements associated with the launch of the 3rd Gen Intel® Xeon® Scalable processor, Intel also disclosed some breakthrough FPGA news: Intel® Agilex™ FPGAs now deliver industry-leading power efficiency and performance.

Click here for more information about Intel® Agilex™ FPGAs.

featured paper

Intel® Agilex™ FPGAs target IPUs, SmartNICs, and 5G Networks White Paper

Sponsored by Intel

Security challenges in the form of cyberattacks and data breaches loom ever larger as attacks on high-speed networks multiply. Massive amounts of data are at risk but so are physical resources, including critical physical infrastructure. Cryptography and authentication represent potent countermeasures. The latest members of the Intel® Agilex™ FPGA and SoC FPGA families feature hardened crypto blocks paired with MACsec soft IP to help mitigate the risks and limit the effects of these cyberattacks.

Click to read more

featured chalk talk

IsoMOV

Sponsored by Mouser Electronics and Bourns

Today, your circuit protection device needs to be versatile, handling a wide range of conditions with long-life low capacitance, low leakage, and state-of-the-art energy handling density. In this episode of Chalk Talk, Amelia Dalton chats with Paul Smith from Bourns about IsoMOV - a new integrated circuit protection that brings together the most important circuit protection capabilities in one efficient package.

Click here for more information about Bourns IsoMOV™ Series Hybrid Protection Component