feature article
Subscribe Now

Tools for the Gifted

Packet Plus Brings Debugging to Networking Engineers

Networking engineers are some of the best and brightest among us.  There are good reasons for this.  Designing networking equipment is a demanding discipline, spanning a wide gamut of areas from analog and signal integrity to digital design to software – and integrating all of these elements at something near their maximum performance potential.  In order to get a competitive piece of network hardware out the door, you are literally designing at the bleeding edge of everything.

One problem common to all bleeding-edge engineering domains is a lack of tools.  While the B and C students cruise along in their daily lives supported by a robust ecosystem of pre-designed engineering tools that do half of their job for them, the A+ engineers who live on the edge typically do not have the luxury of advanced productivity tools.  When you’re the first explorer on the new frontier, nobody has arrived before you to build roads.  It’s as simple as that.

Packet Plus is ready to break that mold.  They are bringing a system to market that gives the networking engineer a robust set of control, analysis, and debugging capabilities that have never been available in the rare air of new protocols and high-performance packet processing.  If you work on the design of networking hardware, these tools could well become your new best friends at work. 

If you want to know what Packet Plus will do for your job designing and debugging your packet-processing hardware, get up from your desk and walk down the cube row…  Find one of the software engineers who work at your company.  Introduce yourself and make friends (this may be the most difficult part).  Next, get the software engineer to show you their IDE.  If you’ve never done software before, be prepared to be amazed.  When they have a bug in their code, they can set breakpoints, stop, single step, go backward, push new data into registers, examine variables and memory… in short, they have debugging superpowers. 

Now, go back to your own desk.  I’m guessing, (and I’m not really going out on a limb here) that you have no such superpowers.  Zero.  OK, you may have a tiny bit of debug superpowers, but nothing like the software dude down the hall.  What you probably have today is a home-grown test harness that blasts a bunch of packets through your FPGA prototype board, creates a big ’ol log file, and then lets you poke around in the debris field to figure out what happened.  I’ll further guess (and I am going out on a little bit of a limb here) that the person who put together that home-grown test harness is one of your junior engineers who didn’t know what they were getting into when they found out their first project was to put together the stuff to evaluate and debug your prototype hardware. 

Are we right so far?

Enter Packet Plus – a company who, for whatever reason, has heard your cries and has descended from the ether to hand you a full-fledged debugging, control, and analysis tool that might even make your new software buddy jealous.  It works just like his IDE, only it speaks your language: Packets.  Through the magic of Packet Plus, you can interact with your live system on a packet-by-packet basis.  You can set breakpoints/triggers, single-packet step, and observe every bit of data within your design – at any protocol level.  You can directly edit packets still in the queue and see the results of your changes play out in real time.  For debugging packet-processing hardware, it’s everything your software engineer enjoys – with the bonus that you don’t have to stoop to writing software.  OK, that was harsh. Sorry software engineers.  (Hey, why are you reading this article anyway?)

Magic, eh?  OK, we’ll fess up.  It’s not magic.  As we pointed out at the beginning of the article, you are A+ engineers and don’t believe in magic.  Fair enough.  Packet Plus delivers to your desktop a box called the P+ 1000 Embedded Packet Debugger.  Not a catchy name, is it?  These guys are serious nerds, with no time or penchant for fancy marketing names.  The P+ 1000 hooks up to your prototype hardware (most likely an FPGA board), to a PC for control and diagnostics, as well as to things like logic analyzers and spectrum analyzers.  Yep, that logic analyzer that’s been gathering dust because you had no way to hook in the probes, you can bring it back out again.  

Now, if you’re thinking of forwarding this article to your QA team and going back to browsing your Dilbert book from 1995, hang on a minute.  You’re missing the point.  This tool is actually meant for design engineers.  Instead of doing your debug iterations through long loops of setup, run, log, analyze, change, re-build, setup – ad nauseum, you can get right in and get your virtual hands virtually dirty.  You can pick and place packets, watch where they go, change the data, and watch them go again – all with a nice graphical user interface that’s worlds ahead of that script your junior team member wrote – even when his script is working.  You can do this work at any protocol level you choose.  (We think most of you will choose 2).  Unlike the software IDE we were discussing, you can even insert new packets into the stream.  This is much more than a protocol analyzer.  Yes, the QA folks might like it and may even want to give it a go someday, but for now this should probably be your little secret.

We’ve talked about the P+ 1000 box, but I hear you already asking how this thing hooks up to your design, and how Packet Plus gives you the level of control we’ve been discussing.  Physically, the box connects to your prototype through either Ethernet, SFP fiber, or a proprietary interface.  If FPGA-based prototyping boards from the Dini Group are your platform, there is a custom module that should plug you right in.  Inside your design, the secret sauce is a very small IP block that, when strategically placed, controls your design and manages the packet queue while conversing with the P+ 1000 box outside.  That means there is you, your PC and analysis tools, the P+ 1000 box, and your prototype (decked out with the tiny IP block inside).  Fire it up and take command.  You control the horizontal.  You control the vertical.  See? That QA kid has no idea what we’re talking about.

What if your design involves security protocols?  For a nominal additional fee, Packet Plus will set you up to handle and debug those as well.  Virtually any common security protocol can be supported, with at-speed operation (trigger, view, edit in the clear), and the embedded hardware block approach makes security protocol support easily extensible.  With security protocol support turned on, you get encryption and decryption, key management, and programmable nonce.  Not only can you debug inside of your security-enabled system, you can debug the security itself – validating, for example, that the system properly rejects an outdated key. 

A nice feature of the system is that it can be used easily at your desk.  You don’t have to have a huge setup in the “lab” where you are not allowed to take your can of Mt. Dew (unless it’s late at night and your lab buddy promises not to tell).  It’s also cheap enough where you don’t have to buy one for the whole company to share.  Starting at around $9500 a copy for an individual engineer, you’re important enough to get your own.

The reason we haven’t had a tool like this before is probably obvious.  You’re not working on developing hardware for the old, well-worn protocols.  You’re developing hardware for the next one – the one that isn’t out yet.  By the time somebody came up with a tool for that, you’d have moved on down the road.  The reason Packet Plus can help you out is that they’ve developed a protocol description language, which they use to very quickly support new protocols with their same proprietary hardware box and IP.  In most cases, they should be able to come into your place and have your FPGA design up and instrumented in less than a day.  In a year, when you are working on a completely different design, they can easily upgrade the system to whatever whiz-bang protocol you will be working on then.  

It’s not often that we get a commercial tool designed for the cutting-edge designer.  Most of the mainstream test and measurement companies are happy to bring mainstream capabilities to mainstream engineers.   We find it refreshing to see something new and awesome like this for the trendsetters as well.  For engineers designing today’s complex pipelined architectures for networking gear, this could be a major productivity tool once you’re in the debugging phase with a hardware prototype. 

5 thoughts on “Tools for the Gifted”

  1. If I am not mistaken, wireshark is a post-processing protocol analyzer. It does not let you stop, edit and insert packets in the queue, then single step, etc. This is a true “runtime debugger” type of tool, where I’d say wireshark is not.

  2. Yes wireshark doesn’t falls in the category of debugger tool. It provides only inspection and analyzing functions.

    Still I am not convinced with Packet Plus debugging capabilities. I think the open source tools are a pretty good option for debugging. What are the benefits that this tool is providing that open source tools doesn’t.

    If I am not wrong this debugger itself would be an embedded target running with some flavor of Linux and a software running on top of it.

  3. Yes, there are several open source tools that are useful, including Wireshark and SCAPY, among others. The P+ 1000 provides additional control and interactivity that is not available with any open source or other commercial tools.

    For example, using a P+ 1000 the live, real-time traffic can be scanned for a combination of field values at many different levels of the networking stack. When this complex condition is met, the P+ 1000 can interrupt the flow of packets to/from the target system. While in this triggered state, the P+ 1000 continues to buffer new packet arrivals so there is no packet loss. The triggered state allows a user modify packets before they are input to the target system, insert additional packets, and input the packet stream to the target system in a controlled, packet-by-packet manner.

    These capabilities cannot be replicated by just running software on a target.

    — Packet Plus

Leave a Reply

featured blogs
Oct 23, 2020
The Covid-19 pandemic continues to impact our lives in both expected and unexpected ways. Unfortunately, one of the expected ways is a drop in charitable donations. Analysts predict anywhere from a 6% decrease '€“ with many planning for a bigger decline than that. Also, mor...
Oct 23, 2020
[From the last episode: We noted that some inventions, like in-memory compute, aren'€™t intuitive, being driven instead by the math.] We have one more addition to add to our in-memory compute system. Remember that, when we use a regular memory, what goes in is an address '...
Oct 23, 2020
Any suggestions for a 4x4 keypad in which the keys aren'€™t wobbly and you don'€™t have to strike a key dead center for it to make contact?...
Oct 23, 2020
At 11:10am Korean time this morning, Cadence's Elias Fallon delivered one of the keynotes at ISOCC (International System On Chip Conference). It was titled EDA and Machine Learning: The Next Leap... [[ Click on the title to access the full blog on the Cadence Community ...

featured video

Better PPA with Innovus Mixed Placer Technology – Gigaplace XL

Sponsored by Cadence Design Systems

With the increase of on-chip storage elements, it has become extremely time consuming to come up with an optimized floorplan with manual methods. Innovus Implementation’s advanced multi-objective placement technology, GigaPlace XL, provides automation to optimize at scale, concurrent placement of macros, and standard cells for multiple objectives like timing, wirelength, congestion, and power. This technology provides an innovative way to address design productivity along with design quality improvements reducing weeks of manual floorplan time down to a few hours.

Click here for more information about Innovus Implementation System

featured Paper

New package technology improves EMI and thermal performance with smaller solution size

Sponsored by Texas Instruments

Power supply designers have a new tool in their effort to achieve balance between efficiency, size, and thermal performance with DC/DC power modules. The Enhanced HotRod™ QFN package technology from Texas Instruments enables engineers to address design challenges with an easy-to-use footprint that resembles a standard QFN. This new package type combines the advantages of flip-chip-on-lead with the improved thermal performance presented by a large thermal die attach pad (DAP).

Click here to download the whitepaper

Featured Chalk Talk

Evaluation and Development Kits

Sponsored by Samtec

With signal integrity becoming increasingly challenging in today’s designs, interconnect is taking on a key role. In order to see how a particular interconnect solution will perform in our design, we really need hands-on evaluation of the technology. In this episode of Chalk Talk, Amelia Dalton chats with Matthew Burns of Samtec about evaluation and development kits for high-speed interconnect solutions.

More information about Samtec Evaluation and Development Kits